On Problems, Predicaments, and Responses
To say that the present post-industrial age has its share of problems is perhaps, at best, an understatement. I think the urgency of the challenges we face been exasperated here in the US by a radically shifting political climate where even basic human decency, access to clean environment, and former structures are breaking down around us at an alarming rate. When looking at these challenges, particularly large-scale environmental ones, we begin to ask “What can we do?” What should we do? How do we solve this problem?” And while some of the issues facing us may well be problems, the larger issue is a much more complex predicament, and that changes the nature of how we respond and what we do. A problem, as John Michael Greer has so cautioned us over a decade ago, has a clear solution. With the threats to human survival and the survival of many other species on this planet, the term “problem” doesn’t quite do it justice. A problem is something like a flat tire: there are a few solutions to fix it (patch it, put on a spare, buy a new tire) and they are fairly limited. Predicaments, on the other hand, are an entirely different matter. Predicaments, unlike problems, don’t have clear solutions. They are issues so multifaceted, so interconnected, so complex, that any “solution” fails to address the scope and enormity of it and instead require a large range of responses. John Michael argues that the issues we face in our current age–of the limits of a finite planet, of climate change, of environmental turmoil are predicaments. To respond, we must find our own ways forward, ways of responding, and a plurality of ways is often necessary. But how do we even begin to respond to that?
This is the question that many open-eyed, connected, nature-honoring folks are asking at present: what the heck are we going to do about what is going on? What exactly is going on? What can we do? How can we do it while still providing for our basic needs? How can we thrive in a world that seems to be socially, politically, environmentally, and emotionally crumbling? In fact, almost everyone out there who has any connection at all to the living earth struggles with the disconnection between what it takes to survive in this current world and where their value systems lie and leveraging a response. It is a fact that stares each of us squarely in the face often and powerfully. As I’ve worked my way deeper into my to the problem we face as a species and civilization over the better part of my adult life, I’ve certainly tried my own range of responses.
While I believe the most important thing, in the end, is to respond (rather than ignore the issue) it takes nearly all of us a while to get to the point of having a response we feel good about. I meet druids all the time who are distraught about what is happening and want to do something but don’t have the skills or tools to actually do it, or aren’t sure what to do, or are working through their emotions about it–and feeling guilty all the less for not doing anything. And to them I say, we are not trying to climb Mount Davis (the tallest mountain here in the Laurel Highlands of PA) in one day. But we can take steps there with each thought and action, and that’s an important part of responding, and working through those steps, and addressing the time that they take, is a big part of what we’ll explore in the remainder of this post today.
Polycultures and a Multitude of Responses
Any healthy ecosystem is not made up of a single species of plant (monoculture), but a multitude of plants (a polyculture). We see this in any forest or wild area–you can see thousands of species interacting within a single space and thriving together, often working together to benefit the larger system. Polycultures outperform monocultures in every way: they outproduce them, they offer many different kinds of yields, they offer resiliency, and they offer redundancy in the case of a single plant or plant species failing. Nature loves, and creates, polycultures (and gardeners practicing permaculture do as well!)
I think the polyculture metaphor is a great one to help us understand the multitude of responses we need for the predicament we face. My response, my life choices, aren’t yours, and shouldn’t be. Each of us, given our unique circumstances, our sets of skills, or commitments to others, our work lives, and so on, must work to find our own response to add to the larger polyculture of responses. For some people, their response is retiring to a little piece of land in the country and “pulling out” of broader affairs to live a more simple life. For others, it is activism on the front lines, marching, meeting, and demonstrating. For some of us, it is coming together to build something anew. The thing is–there is no right or wrong way to respond. There are responses. Some may be more effective than others in the long run. It is with a polyculture of responses that we have a chance at success–for even if one or multiple responses fail, some will succeed and thrive, as we see in an ecosystem.
Towards Responding through Thought and Action: Composting and Soil Preparation
In druidry, we understand that the inner realms reflect the outer, and that the outer realms reflect inward. I believe responses begin within, in the realm of thought, contemplation, and meditation. My first piece of hard-earned advice is this: recognize that this larger predicament is a tremendous amount for a human to process and many of us need a good amount of processing time before finding our own response. This is an important step: our responses will take years, decades, a lifetime to engage with and understand. Part of this thinking process is just working on acceptance of what is happening so that you can respond. It takes a lot to pull our heads out of this culture, look at the evidence, emotionally and intellectually process it, and decide what to do. That is critically important work and we need to be kind to ourselves while we are doing it. Sometimes, it is also ok to pause and regroup before barreling forward with what we feel is a correct response. Otherwise, we end up in a place where we’ve thought we’ve made good choices–radically so–and then they turn out to be not as good (or as sustainable or sustaining) as we thought! Of course, the nature of the predicament and the continued speed at which things are declining makes it hard to give us the time to process and to allow the seed to incubate, leading to guilt, frustration, and more.
Like many living in the Northern Hemisphere in the spring months, I have been (physically) planting my seeds for the coming year. Small seeds of St. John’s wort, sacred tobacco, catnip, many veggies, and so many other herbs. Seeds are so magical: they have so much potential stored up in a little hard shell. As I carefully prepare the soil and push each one in, I am struck by the cycle of life within a seed. I see our own responses to this predicament just like a seed I plant: it needs time for incubation, dormancy, sprouting, and growth–growing seeds are a process, and I think growing responses are too.
And so, before we begin to plant the seeds of a response, we must tend to our soil, compost the old, and prepare the ground for new beginnings. I have been in this exact situation for the last two years, and it has at points been very frustrating. Long-term blog readers know that I’ve struggled tremendously with my own response to the predicament, and that response has changed over time. Since I became a druid over a decade ago, it was really important that I *do something* but I wasn’t always sure what that something was. My first “doing something” altered permanently my major long-term relationship at the time (as we were going in different directions with different worldviews). It led me to own a homestead in the country and do everything myself (and eventually burn out, leaving to regroup). It has taken me down the road of exploring a host of issues surrounding “everyday life”: work-life balance, waste, consumerism, food, family, friendships, and more. It led me to temporarily “regroup” and explore urban homesteading options and a walkable lifestyle in a small town where I had to reflect, regroup, and work on my next response.
And as hard as it has been to feel like I’m doing less than living my full truth as I’ve been in this composting and preparation phase, I now realize that it has been time well spent. I haven’t done anything radical or big with my life (or finances) that would be hard to undo, but rather, found niches and small things I could do while I was in this “dormant” period with my larger life goals. I’ve lived simply, walked to work, did a lot of wildtending, weed walking, spent a ton of time studying and building my oak knowledge and reskilling, reconnected with my ancestral land, engaged my community in plant walks, herbalism, worked on a lot of my own writing and artistic projects, did a lot of small-scale urban homesteading that I could do…all while really contemplating my choices. I learned a lot, a grew a lot, but I also felt very “unsettled” as I was focused only on the small things and on not doing the things I felt I really needed to do. I felt like I wasn’t doing enough. Now, I realize that A) I was doing a lot more good work than I thought I was and B) this time to regroup and contemplate was necessary. Making a choice too soon would have actually hampered my long-term goals (although I couldn’t have possibly known that a year ago!)
I think a lot of us find ourselves in this place, and it can be a frustrating place to be. It’s a mix of things: wanting to do something, but not being sure what we can or should do, and feeling increasing pressure to do something quickly given all that is happening in the broader world. It kind of makes you feel like you want to explode! If you find yourself here, waiting and dormant, remember that this is part of your response, part of your work, and it is a very important part.
I think this “incubation” time has been a very difficult time for me in many ways: not being on land, and being rooted in a specific piece of property where I could explore has left me feeling really disconnected, unsure of my path forward, and yet, it has also allowed me to be in a space of new possibilities. And that’s what’s so powerful about these transitory times: they are unsettling, and net, incredibly powerful. Anything can happen, anything that you can dream up might occur. You don’t have a clear path forward, but you have an ample amount of hope and possibility. In the Tarot, the “tower” is an incredibly difficult place to be: the structures we have aren’t working (societally and personally), and given that, they must come down, and the dust must settle before we are to see the way forward.
Planting the Seeds of a Response
The next phase in the journey of a seed and the journey of our own responses to the larger predicament is that period of planting. This is a huge transition: the period between thinking about responding and beginning to respond (even if the efforts themselves haven’t yet been seen). The move towards some action, however, small, is incredible. We have already tended the soil and done our composting work–and now, we plant the seeds and wait for them to sprout. Incubation can also be a difficult period of time. I know after I’ve planted seeds, the hardest thing is waiting–seeing if they will germinate. Sometimes they don’t, and then we have to plant again, or plant different seeds, or change something about the conditions under which we plant them (heat mat, light exposure, cold stratification, scarification, etc.). Sometimes seeds require fire to sprout–burning away the old and creating fertile soil. Some seeds are simply harder to start than others–but well worth the extra effort and cultivation.
Planting the seeds is the critical difference between thought and action. In the end, as I’ve argued on this blog, it is our actions that count–it is our actions that help us enact change, live in harmony, and come up with an effective range of responses.
Germination, Growth and Change
And then, the magic happens. After an indefinite period of incubation, the seed we have planted comes out of dormancy and the spark of life, nwyfre, flows. The seed sprouts and life is born. The beautiful, tender sprout emerges from the soil and you can continue the careful work of cultivating this seed into an incredible healing and nourishing plant. And yet, seeds are so fragile–once that sprout emerges, it can so quickly dry up, or rot, or not have enough life. Part of what we must do is ensure that we tend the seed as carefully as possible during the early stages of any response.
Congratulations Dana. I wish you great success in your new project.
Hugs from Max
Thank you, Max! It is a very exciting time in this journey 🙂
I’ve never commented, but have been following your blog for a few years. Your posts are so inspiring and motivating. I’ve been reading about permaculture and interested in so many of the things you write about for awhile, but you have a way of making them accessible and practical to do. Thank you!
I have felt the need for some type of transition in my life for several years also, so today’s post especially resonates. In fact, I’m registered for a pdc course this summer that I’m so excited about. I really want to do something in our community, and am slowly making some connections but it’s good to know that taking it slowly is ok too. I have a good job and 2 young boys, so my enthusiasm is definitely tempered by my available time. I’m excited to hear more about your new project, if I lived anywhere near I would love to be a part of it, but I’m way over in south Dakota. Best wishes!
Hello Robin – thank you so much for commenting and for reading! 🙂 I’m excited to hear about your PDC and some of the work you are doing. You mentioned that you have two young boys–I’m sure they would gain much from being part of any permaculture projects that come out of the PDC course! I have seen some amazing things people are doing with children and permaculture–it is transformative. Thank you for writing!
Reblogged this on Rattiesforeverworldpresscom.
Wow! I wish you all the best in this exciting, collaborative adventure! I’m looking forward to hearing more about your experience, joys and warts and all. Thanks so much for sharing, which in itself can fuel the awen in others. It definitely does me!
Thanks Talis! It is an exciting time. We’ve been living in community for a month now. I can’t believe how much work we have to do to start this–everything from legal structures to figuring out what everyone wants in a piece of land (we’ve been starting to look), and so on. The good news is that we have outlined our overall goals and shared vision, and are working to visit other communities, etc. There’s a lot to think about–and I certainly will document our progress here!
My friends and I wanted to start a little community like that as well 🙂. I don’t know if we’ll get to, but I’m glad to hear that you have been able to accomplish it 😊
Well, we are in stage one. The key will be seeing if we can get to stage 2 – buying the land and really establishing the larger community. There’s a lot to do between stage one (small communal living) and stage 2 (the full blown community), but we are on our journey!