The question of how to respond to events beyond our control, the broader events and decisions that continue shape the world, is an important one. So much destructive and exploitative human activity is taking place (fracking, mountain top mining, tar sands oil) and its hard to respond when we feel so powerless. Its even harder to respond when we know that we are complicit in these events’ creation–by driving cars, heating our homes with gas, and so on, we are shaping the events that take place.
The kinds of responses we generate in the face of such events is an issue well worth pursuing. Each area has its own local challenges, my area being no exception. As I’ve discussed on this blog before, the area in South-East Michigan where I live (less than 3 miles north of my house) has a tar sands oil pipeline being put in (this line is an alternative to Keystone XL, which has generated substantial attention in the media). While there is nothing that the citizens can do here to prevent the pipeline from being completed due to the history of this particular pipeline and previous permission being granted, we can certainly decide how we respond, how we work with the land, and what we do after the pipeline crews leave. How we choose to respond can shape conversations about these activities for decades to come, and can demonstrate that there are many ways to work with the land and address change.
Last fall, I discussed the Enbridge Oil Pipeline digging project that was going through my good friend Deanne’s land at Strawbale Studio. In the fall, I went and worked with the trees and documented what was happening on her land. At this point, the land has been cleared for the crews, and the pipeline will be dug within the next few weeks. Those of us involved with Strawbale Studio been thinking about what to do when the crews leave, how we might encourage sustainable thinking and practices.
Last night, 35 members of the Oakland County Permaculture Meetup spent time looking at the site in its current form and brainstorming ideas for restoration once the pipeline project is done. I wanted to post an update about some of our ideas and suggestions to A) document the progress of this project and our response and B) share the ideas if others are facing a similar challenge in their communities.
We began with a tour of the Strawbale Studio property, ending at the pipeline. Using principles of permaculture design (observe and interact) we examined the site, explored the margins, noted the existing flows of energy (like a wetland area on the western part of the pipeline and a rising slope on the eastern part of the pipeline). Deanne also pointed out the existing resources, including a huge pile of mulched wood chips from the trees that were cut (which will likely become a compost water heater in the fall) and numerous logs and stone piles which could be used for various natural building projects. After reviewing the site, we went back to the house for discussion about possibilities. We also noted the distance from the house (about a 3-5 min walk) and noted the severity of last winter would mean that the site might not be accessible year round. We also noted which areas needed to remain clear of large trees (where the pipeline is) and which areas could be “anything goes” areas (the staging areas where they cleared to have their equipment move in and out around the area where the pipeline is being dug).
Its incredible what happens when you get 35 people in a room who want to make change. We came up with a number of good and worthy suggestions–short term and long term. I’m not sure yet which ones we’ll decide to move forward with, but I think a number of these are worthy of consideration.
Short term suggestions:
Our short term suggestions focused on the immediate needs to restore the land and how to make use of any resources the pipeline company might be willing to provide:
- Seeing if the construction crews would create swales for water trapping and the like, be willing to shape the landscape so we could more effectively catch and store energy (this would be a first response)
- Seeing what kinds of resources for restoration the company offers (they are required to offer some, based on Michigan Department of Natural Resources and EPA guidelines).
- Once the crews leave, we need to immediately get something immediately planted in the bare soil to help restore the land and rebuild the soil ecology. Ideas ranged from a cover crop of rye, clover, alfalfa to something with a tap root. This suggestion is particularly important because the soil ecology has been largely destroyed and now the soil will have substantial amounts of compaction due to the heavy machinery going over the site. A tap rooted crop will help break up compaction and add nitrogen and other minerals back into the soil.
These three areas are the first we will address in the action plan. Once we see what resources we have, what, if anything, we can do to shape the land, and how to get something in the soil to restore it, the longer-term projects can get underway.
Long-Term Potential Projects:
The long-term projects ranged substantially, and many have a lot of merit! Which projects end up taking place depends on the community, the resources, and Deanne’s vision for the site.
- A camping area (perhaps combined with a yearly gathering) where interns or visitors can camp.
- A pollinator sanctuary with native wild grasses, plants, flowers, etc., as well as beehives for honey and a cob beehive for wild bees (like mason bees). We like this idea a lot because it doesn’t require a lot of daily maintenance (like animals would, see below), and it contributes back to the land.
- The use of the land for natural building materials for other strawbale projects–establishing trees for coppicing (hazels, willows), perhaps other materials
- Some kind of co-op: wine/grapes, orchard/fruit; goat/sheep; chicken/egg; or herbs. The idea is that the community would contribute to the work of the co-op and reap some of the rewards.
- An education area for children/school groups to come and learn about energy and restoration–it would have signs about oil pipelines, what was done and how the oil is used, encouraging reduction of fossil fuel use and teaching about sustainability (this could be done with any number of our ideas)
- Orchards of fruit and nut trees (Hazels and Apples were specifically discussed)
- A grazing area for chickens, goats, horses, or the like (we decided that if this were to be, someone would need to be down there in a little cob building as a caretaker!)
- Alfalfa as a cash crop that can be baled and sold to nearby farmers (to bring in steady income for other projects)
These are just some of the ideas the community came up with. This was a wonderful meeting, to see so many people invested in planning for the future, in reclaiming the land and in working to put something in that encourages a different worldview.
Throughout our country and world, there are a lot of bad things being done to the land in pursuit of cheap fossil fuel energy. Any of us who participates in modern consumerist society (myself included) is contributing to the problem of the exploitation of our lands for oil. And most of us live near some kind of activity–from mountaintop removal to fracking to oil pipelines (and many of us live in areas were multiple kinds of activity are taking place).
While we can reduce our fossil fuel use and look for alternatives (as many of us are doing), how we respond to these kinds of issues, especially when we are directly confronted with them can empower us and bring about broader change in the world. That we will turn the oil pipeline site into a sustainable, model site for other kind of restorative work is empowering–and its something we *have* the power to do, while stopping the oil pipeline is something that we really don’t have the power to do (this one was leased in the 1960’s, so its a done deal as far as any of us can tell). I’d be interested in hearing of any other communities’ responses to these kinds of issues.
Reblogged this on OurPantheons.
You’re welcome. 🙂
I really appreciate the extremely educational pieces you post. The post not only educates me on many different things but it also gets me excited and fired up about the topics. Thank you for posting so diligently on this stuff!
My thoughts/opinions on this particular project (needed or not ^_^;; ) :
It really depends on the amount of space available to work with, but I would put my vote for the long-term plans to be a combination of several suggestions listed. Please please please absolutely do an educational area not matter what else is decided on! I would be sure to come and visit from the western side of the mitten 😉 Alfalfa as a cash crop and a pollinator sanctuary sound like the best starting combination for that since both the alfalfa and the honey could fairly quickly generate income for future projects, especially the time- and labor-intensive animal-based ideas. Apple uses from trees planted could be a more long-term fund-generating option also. If the educational things really take off then a few camping options would be a smart followup move. Unless tree-based plans would be to focus of the restoration projects, I think planting trees in coordination with other projects (i.e. which trees and where would be best for bees or horses or sheep etc) would be helpful also.
While I may not precisely be what one would call “local” to these projects, I would still like to help in whatever ways that I can! 😀 Whatever the outcomes, I’m very glad that Deanne and Strawbale Studio have such a great community for support 🙂
Thank you so much for your comments! Yes, I think a combination of strategies might be what we decide….the pipeline won’t be finished for several months, so we have more time to see the project through to the end :).
Good luck on finding a workable set of responses! I think you’ve got some excellent options on the table.
With regard to restorative planting, I suggest that you look into the feasibility of trying to combine a taproot crop (dandelions, burdock, etc) with a cover crop (rye, clover, etc) so that you can work on restoring soil health at multiple levels at the same time. I know that burdock and clover, for example, or dandelions and clover, can grow and thrive together without harmful competition for space and resources.
Yes, thanks for the tip, Sara G!
I really appreciate your response – figuring out positive actions you can do.
Good reminder and great role model.
[…] Photos and writing by Dana Driscoll […]